Article 4 of the Constitution

The United States Constitution is the oldest constitution in the world still in active use. It was written in 1787 and officially ratified in 1788.

Article 4 of the Constitution Summary

Article 4 of the United States Constitution addresses the roles and responsibilities of the states. This was a topic of great importance when it was written, given the increased power states enjoyed in the pre-Civil War era. Also due to the fact that the Articles of Confederation didn’t give enough power to the states.

Article 4 is composed of four distinct sections, each of which describes various aspects of the states and their duties. Some of these sections are further divided into separate clauses.

Article 4, Section 1

Article 4, Section 1 requires all states to respect and accept each others’ public acts, records, and judicial proceedings.

It also grants Congress the authority to create general legislation that defines how public acts, records, and judicial proceedings are recognized and respected across state lines.

What problem did Article 4, Section 1 solve?

Section 1 provided a vital solution to the discord and disunity among states under the original Articles of Confederation. This disunity was particularly noticeable during the early stages of the Revolutionary War.

Under the previous system, each state would print its own currency, operate under different forms of government, and have vastly different cultures and economies.

The success of the union of states depended on the cooperation of the states under the guiding hand of a centralized government, particularly the legislative branch.

Article 4, Section 2

Clause 1

Article 4, Section 2, Clause 1 guaranteed that citizens would have the same privileges and immunities in every state. This promised individual citizens the same basic rights and freedoms as they traveled to other states.

In addition, it prevented states from discriminating against people from other states.

Clause 2

Article 4, Section 2, Clause 2 is an extradition provision for states, requiring a criminal to be returned from the state to which they fled, to the jurisdiction of the state where they committed their crimes.

The state where the person fled could not refuse to give up the criminal. This was a necessary provision to maintain a level of law and order in an otherwise free society.

Clause 3

Article 4, Section 2, Clause 3 is the Fugitive Slave Clause. The Fugitive Slave Clause prohibits slaves from escaping their servitude by fleeing to another state, even if the state they fled to prohibits slavery. 

The state government where the slave ran were obligated to return them to their original owner.

The 13th Amendment, passed in 1865, has rendered this clause obsolete by abolishing slavery and any form of involuntary servitude. The exception is the case of punishment for a convicted criminal.

The 13th Amendment, passed in 1865, rendered this clause obsolete by abolishing slavery and all forms of involuntary servitude, except in cases of punishment for convicted criminals

Section 3

Clause 1

Article 4, Section 3, Clause 1 permits the admission of new states into the United States, which became necessary due to the westward expansion of many American colonies.

If a new state formed from within the boundary of another state or states, both Congress and state legislatures would have to approve the measure.

Get Smarter on US News, History, and the Constitution

Join the thousands of fellow patriots who rely on our 5-minute newsletter to stay informed on the key events and trends that shaped our nation's past and continue to shape its present.

Please leave this field empty

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

This process has largely been followed in the formation of all states in the United States. However, it was tenuously applied when West Virginia was formed from the existing state of Virginia in 1863.

Formation of West Virginia

Amid the Civil War, residents of the western mountainous region of Virginia petitioned Abraham Lincoln to form a separate state from Virginia. Part of the reason is that they were staunchly against slavery.

Unfortunately, while the measure gained approval from what was left of Congress after the Confederate states seceded, it had no chance of getting approval from the Virginia legislature, currently in rebellion.

A hastily formed provisional “Virginia” state legislature was assembled in Wheeling, Virginia.

It approved the formation of that particular state, technically fulfilling the requirements of the constitution that both the state and Congress had to approve a measure to form a new state within its boundary. 

Whether or not this fulfilled the requirements outlined in the clause is still a topic of debate.

Clause 2

Article 4, Section 3, Clause 2 gives Congress the legislative power over any territory or other property owned by the United States, with the right to pass laws and regulations for their governance.

Congress is also given the right to dispose of any territory or property owned by the United States.

For example, if the United States desired to sell the territory they purchased from Napoleon Bonaparte of France in the Louisiana Purchase to another foreign state, they would have every right to do so.

Section 4

Article 4, Section 4 requires Congress to guarantee every state in the country a republican form of government.

Both existing and newly formed states were protected from the takeover of a potentially tyrannical government that would oppress their rights at the state level.

It is important to note that Section 4 is a broad provision and that no specific guidelines are given about how Congress would accomplish this, implying that it is the responsibility of the individual states to formulate their government.

On the other hand, Congress would play a more indirect role of simply verifying that the state government is indeed a republican form of government and then approving and admitting that particular state into the union.

Federal Government guarantees the safety of states from a foreign state

Section 4 also ensures the protection of every state from invasion, a necessary provision given the disjointed war effort that characterized the early days of the Revolutionary War.

Many New England colonies (Massachusetts in particular) found themselves in a state of war in 1775 with the Battles of Lexington, Concord, and Bunker Hill. 

However, many of the other colonies insisted that they were not at war with England, refusing to recognize the conflict of Massachusetts as a legitimate war shared by all the colonies.

If the union of 13 colonies, now states, were to survive in times of war, the federal government would have to unify and guarantee the safety of all of them.

Federal jurisdiction and necessary rules to ensure security

Finally, Section 4 guarantees the safety of individual states from domestic violence under the authority of the legislative branch or, if the legislative branch cannot meet in time to diffuse the situation, the executive branch.

This portion of Section 4 is the basis of the federal government interfering in the civil unrest characteristic of the Civil Rights era of the 1960s.

Key points of each section of Article 4 of the US Constitution:

Article 4 Quiz

If you would like to download a PDF with our quiz, then please go to:

Download the quiz PDF

Alternatively, you can take our online quiz here:

Article 4 Quiz

Start quiz

{{$pages}}

{{$questions}}

{{question_title}}

{{#if has_image}}

{{#if image:description}}

{{image:description}}

{{/if}}

{{/if}}

{{$answers}}

{{#if has_answer_with_image}}

{{#if has_image}}

{{#if image:description}}

{{image:description}}

{{/if}}

{{/if}}

{{/if}}

{{answer_title}} 

{{/answers}}

{{/questions}}

Continue

{{/pages}}

Continue

{{$global}}

Article 4 Quiz

You got {{userScore}} out of {{maxScore}} correct

{{title}}

{{image}}

{{content}}

{{/global}}