Sources
- https://www.c-span.org/presidentsurvey2021/
C-SPAN's Presidential Historians Survey provides a comprehensive ranking of U.S. presidents based on leadership qualities, making it an authoritative source for evaluating presidential legacies. - https://www.usnews.com/news/special-reports/the-worst-presidents
US News & World Report's special report on the worst presidents offers detailed analysis and historical context, aligning well with the blog post's discussion of controversial and ineffective leaders. - https://www.history.com/news/worst-presidents-us-history
History.com's article on the worst U.S. presidents provides historical insights and expert opinions, supporting the blog's claims about presidents like Andrew Johnson and James Buchanan. - https://www.britannica.com/list/10-of-the-most-influential-presidents-of-the-united-states
Britannica's list of influential presidents includes context on both effective and ineffective leaders, offering a balanced perspective that complements the blog's focus on presidential rankings. - https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2020/02/10/worst-presidents-ranked-111961
Politico's ranking of the worst presidents includes modern and historical figures, providing relevant commentary on presidents like Donald Trump and George W. Bush.
Key Points
- Ranking presidents is a divisive topic with varying criteria like war involvement, scandals, and public opinion.
- Donald Trump is often cited as one of the worst due to criticism over his skills, intelligence, and integrity, along with two impeachments.
- Andrew Johnson is frequently ranked poorly due to conflicts with Congress and his impeachment following Lincoln's assassination.
- James Buchanan is criticized for his ineptitude during the Civil War crisis.
- Franklin Pierce is blamed for policies that contributed to the Civil War, like the Kansas-Nebraska Act.
- Millard Fillmore's Fugitive Slave Act and unpopularity with his own party place him among the worst.
- Warren G. Harding is remembered for corruption, notably the Teapot Dome scandal.
- Herbert Hoover's presidency is marred by the Great Depression and the rise of 'Hooverville' camps.
- Richard Nixon's Watergate scandal and resignation make him a contender for the worst.
- George W. Bush's War on Terror and misinformation about Iraq's WMDs are significant black marks.
- Presidents who died early in their terms, like William Henry Harrison and Zachary Taylor, left little legacy due to their short tenures.
Summary
The blog post explores the debate over who ranks as the worst U.S. presidents, highlighting factors like scandals, poor leadership, and public opinion. It lists ten contenders, including Donald Trump, Andrew Johnson, and Herbert Hoover, noting their controversies, failures, or negative legacies. The discussion emphasizes that rankings vary based on criteria, with Civil War-era presidents and modern leaders often facing the harshest criticism.
There is a fascination with ranking presidents to see how they compare. Presidents want to end their term with a good legacy that places them in at least the top 10 rather than the bottom 10.
From tyrants and buffoons to misinformed and misguided leaders, these presidents left a lasting mark on the nation, but not always for the better.
So, who are the contenders for the worst president ever of the United States?
A Divisive Topic of Conversation
Some will say that any president that took the nation into war is a clear candidate, while others will focus on major scandals and impeachments.
Historians will consider a more comprehensive record of achievement and failure to find the average.
Then there are the simple factors of public opinion on integrity, intelligence, and personality.
The following list is in no particular order in terms of ranking the past presidents from worst to not quite so bad.
There is too much of a divide in opinion over different criteria to say that one is definitively worse than the other. However, many of these names are found across lists compiled by historians for C-Span, CBS, and US News.
10 of the Worst Presidents To Take Office
Donald Trump
Let’s get this one out of the way first because it is both the most expected and controversial right now.
Many in the United States would argue that he is the worst because there are so many marks against his name.
Critics, including historians placing President Donald Trump high on their list, highlight poor skills, low intelligence, and a lack of integrity as significant factors.
President Trump remains controversial because there is still so much anger over issues regarding attitudes toward immigration and Covid.
There is also the fact that he was impeached twice.
But he may drop down the list when a few more years pass and the dust settles a little.
Andrew Johnson
Johnson is a name that regularly tops the lists created by historians when surveyed on the best and worst presidents.
There isn’t much that is positive to say about Andrew Johnson. He was seen as a difficult man to work with and was often at loggerheads with Congress and his own party around issues regarding the Civil War.
It also doesn’t help that he was following in the footsteps of the assassinated Abraham Lincoln or that he was impeached.
James Buchanan
Many of those deemed to be the worst presidents in American history were in power around the time of the Civil War.
For some, the problem was one of ineptitude.
James Buchanan was in over his head and failed to handle the complexity and urgency of the crisis.
Franklin Pierce
Franklin Pierce is credited with creating policies that would go on to trigger the Civil War. Any president who can take even partial blame for this great national divide will be high on this list.
Get Smarter on US News, History, and the Constitution
The biggest issue was the Kansas-Nebraska Act which allowed territories to define their own slavery laws.
Millard Fillmore
Millard Fillmore‘s position in this list is for similar reasons to Franklin Pierce’s.
He was responsible for the Fugitive Slave Act, where escaped slaves had to be returned to their owners.
He wasn’t well-liked by his own Whig Party and didn’t receive another nomination.
He is also the second on this list to fail after assuming the presidency following a death in office.
Warren G Harding
There are a few parallels between Warren G Harding and Trump. Neither was held in high regard by the public, both enjoyed a round of golf in their spare time, and each was associated with high-profile scandals.
The worst in the case of Harding was the corruption of the oil deals in the Teapot Dome scandal.
Herbert Hoover
Moving forward to the 1900s, Herbert Hoover is a good candidate for the worst of that century. The primary mark against his name is that he was in charge when the nation fell into the Great Depression.
“Hooverville” camps appeared across the country.
Richard Nixon
In keeping with the more modern period, many would argue that Richard Nixon should be on the list.
He is certainly presented as a villain in popular culture.
This primarily stems from his resignation in the aftermath of the Watergate scandal. Some historians argue that he was an effective president until then.
George Bush Jr.
George Bush Jr deserves a place here when discussing modern-day presidents. This is mainly due to the War on Terror’s impact, misinformation surrounding Iraq’s WMDs, and the response to 9/11.
Public opinion has softened in recent years.
Any President That Died in Their First Year
It isn’t easy to round this list out to a clear top 10 because there are so many criteria and mixed opinions.
So, let’s end by looking at two men that barely made an impression.
It is difficult to say that these two men were ineffective presidents when they weren’t around long enough to accomplish anything of note.
The first of these is William Henry Harrison. Harrison now has the reputation of being a foolish president because he did not wear a coat in cold weather at his inauguration, caught pneumonia, and died just 31 days after taking office.
He may have become a great leader if he had survived, but poor decision-making was his downfall.
Then there is Zachary Taylor. He lasted a little longer into his first term but fell ill around Independence Day after indulging in iced milk and cherries. It is believed that contaminated water killed him.
The Worst President of the United States
There is a good chance that the name you were thinking of isn’t here. There is always a case to be made for any president who deals with controversial policies or scandals.
This list highlights the terrible period of leadership around the Civil War, the failures in modern-day presidencies, and others that failed to make a positive mark.
2 Responses
LBJ should be considered this list instead. In spite of his work he was responsible for escalating the Vietnam War. Opinion of him may have changed based on the theory movie JFK. He was not portrayed in a positive light as VP nasa boss in The Right Stuff. Was shocked to see him on the best list.
The list of best and worst completely depends on who puts the list together or who gets surveyed. Democrats of course will put Liberals on the Best List and Republicans on the Worst List. Republicans will do just the opposite. To be fair, there should be a “grading” system, and not an “opinion” system.